2008 recap

2008 Sponsors

2008 Speakers

2008 Exhibitors

2008 Award &
Scholarship Winners

2008 Photos

2007 recap


 


2008 Speakers

COMPARING ODOR TREATMENT TECHNOLOGIES
David Oerke

There is generally increasing public concern and intolerance of odor and other air emissions from wastewater facilities. Management of air emissions has become a significant activity as most wastewater treatment facilities in Alabama and throughout the United States want to be good neighbors. There are several types of odor treatment technologies that can be effectively used to treat foul air emissions from wastewater pump stations and WWTPs. This presentation addresses and compares three common odor treatment technologies: chemical scrubbing, biofiltration and air ionization. The presentation will also highlight features of the biofilter system being installed at the Messerly Water Pollution Control Facility in Augusta, Georgia this year. The purpose of the presentation is to present practical case studies of several odor control studies and design projects that evaluated capital and annual costs, odor treatment effectiveness, flexibility and other evaluation criteria to select the preferred odor treatment technology. Multi-stage chemical scrubbers are used commonly for odor treatment because the process is proven and effective in removing a wide-range of odorants, especially ammonia and hydrogen sulfide. The chemical scrubber operation is flexible and allows a higher degree of treatment with increased chemical dose. However, chemical scrubbers have relatively high O & M cost and many WWTP operators do not like the handling of hazardous chemicals that may be required. Biofilters are one of the most common odor treatment technologies used at wastewater pump stations and WWTPs. They are typically selected because of the lower capital and O & M Costs,
operational simplicity and overall effectiveness. Biofilters can either have an open bed arrangement or enclosed in a vessel. Both inorganic and organic media have been effectively used. However, biofilters require more space than chemical or
biological scrubbers. Air ionization is a relatively new odor treatment technology at pump stations or WWTPs in the United States. However, it has been successfully used in Europe to treat foul air generated from sewers, pump stations, headworks, primary clarifiers, solids storage tanks and solids thickening and dewatering areas at over 75 WWTPs. An ion generator placed in the HVAC ductwork generates millions of positively and negatively charged oxygen molecules, or ions that fill the ventilated room space. These ions form oxygen rich clusters that interact with the foul air in the room and kill bacteria and neutralize the odor. Pilot testing of air ionization is recommended.